American Achievement Corp: Debt On Non Accrual

We learn from Sixth Street Specialty Lending (TSLX), following IVQ 2020 results, that a new portfolio company has been placed on non-accrual: American Achievement Corp. The company “manufactures and supplies yearbooks, class rings and graduation products, and as a result of COVID, underperformed for the 2020 sales season“. TSLX added: “We are currently working with the company on a potential restructuring to keep our term loan outstanding and to receive a majority of the equity in the business as a lender group. We expect to reach resolution on this in the near term“.

What TSLX failed to say is that the company “filed for involuntary Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection January 14, 2021, in the Northern District of Texas“, according to public records. In addition, TSLX did not mention that the near half a billion dollar in debt owed by the company is the subject of heated disputes, which adds an element of uncertainty to the outcome. This article by S&P describes some of the maneuverings underway.

TSLX seems to be (unduly ?) optimistic, writing down its $23.8mn first lien loan by only (9%). Furthermore, if a debt for equity swap – as mentioned above – seems the likeliest resolution, it seems unlikely that the debt will not be subject to a major haircut, which will impact long term income. At the moment, with the non-accrual TSLX has temporarily lost ($2.2mn) of annual investment income.

We have downgraded the company from CCR 2 to CCR 5 in one fell swoop. (As of the IIIQ 2020 TSLX valued its investment at a modest discount of (7%) and no mention was made by TSLX – the only BDC lender – of any challenges at the company). We are also adding AAC – as its known – to our Alerts list because it’s likely that the income, value and outstandings involved will be subject to substantial change in the next couple of quarters.

Frankly, we’re a little disappointed by the transparency of TSLX at this stage. Maybe with so much ill feeling between the parties involved with the company, the BDC did not want to stir up the pot on its February 18, 2021 conference call, but investors are left with an incomplete picture. This a company that bears watching and which we’ve added to our daily review for any new developments.