Last time we wrote about Paper Source Inc., the stationery retailer was bankrupt and Mid Cap Financial – an affiliate of Apollo Global Group – was preparing to acquire the company in a “stalking horse bid”. This would have made Apollo Investment (AINV) – a lender and investor to the company – a part owner (and also likely a lender) to the post-bankruptcy business. AINV as of March 31, 2021 had $16.4mn in debt at cost to Paper Source (its equity stake had no dollars attached) and a value of $13.4mn. For some reason, AINV carried the debt as performing, notwithstanding the bankruptcy.
Anyway, scrub all the above. In the interim, Elliott Management – owner of Barnes and Noble – has swooped in and acquired Paper Source out of bankruptcy for $91.5mn. Here is a link to a trade publication article on the subject, and an extract which explains the appeal of Paper Source to the buyer:
“In a presentation, Elliott described the businesses of Barnes & Noble and Paper Source as “highly complementary, with shared product ranges and a common commitment to excellent customer service.” The investment firm noted that Paper Source will continue to operate independently and keep to its core product offering of greeting cards, stationery,office supplies, gifts and other products. At the same time, Elliott noted that “considerable opportunities exist for mutually beneficial retail partnerships.”
Although Mid Cap/AINV lost the opportunity to acquire Paper Source – something of a mixed blessing given brick and mortar’s endemic challenges regardless of the pandemic – this is probably good news for the BDC. We get the impression the first lien debt – as well as DIP financing recently provided – will be repaid in full. That should allow AINV to post a several million dollar increase in value from the ultimate proceeds, which should show up in the IIQ 2021 results, or by the third quarter at the latest, as the transaction closes.
We may be jumping the gun, but expect to take Paper Source off our underperformers list. Given the potential increase in value, we are adding the company to our Trending List for the IIQ 2021 given the likely upside to be booked. This was never going to be a major setback for AINV and now looks likely to be a minor success. As has been the case on multiple occasions of late, thanks are due to a frothy financial environment and the fast recovery from the pandemic conditions that initially brought the company low.